June 23, 2009

Discipline.

I read an article today that criticized Kate Gosselin for (allegedly) spanking one of her kids. Give me a break. I'm not the biggest fan of Kate Gosselin...I think she's manipulative and snotty, but I think that she did the right thing by spanking her child (it was Hannah, I think.).
I was a nanny, worked in a daycare and have babysat enough children to figure out one thing-spanking works. Although I never spanked a kid, the ones that were spanked by their parents were one million times more well-behaved, articulate and polite than the children whose parents believed in "attachment parenting" or some other nonsense.
At one point, I was taking care of ten 17-24 month olds, and I could point out to you which of the children were spanked when they misbehaved...the ones who weren't were easy to spot, they were the ones laying in the floor screaming, biting or hitting the other kids, or throwing toys across the room.
"Attachment parenting" doesn't work. Reasoning with a screaming 2 year old doesn't work. Begging a 6-year-old monster to behave doesn't work. Bribing doesn't work. When I was a nanny, I worked in the wealthiest part of Birmingham...I can't even count the times I saw skinny, frantic, overly botoxed, top heavy (from their ahem, chest enhancements) women bending over a screeching child, begging them to stop throwing a tantrum. Really? What has society come to, that parents treat kids like their equals? There's no consequences for bad behavior anymore. That's why the world is in the shape it's in, because children are being raised to believe that they can do whatever they want and there won't be any consequences. It's scary, if you think about it.
Parents think they're doing their kids a favor by not punishing them, by not making them pay for bad behavior. It doesn't seem like a huge deal when they're two, but report back to me when they're fifteen, and let me know how that's going for you.

Hmmmph.

5 comments:

Robin said...

GUUURL, I 100% agree with you there! Not that I spank my children a lot, but when the need is there, I don't feel bad about spanking them.

I don't LOVE Kate Gosselin, but I can't imagine not spanking with 8 children!

{{HUGS}}

Robin

Brooke said...

AMEN!!!
There have been plenty of times at work when I want to smack a kid for their behavior. What kills me is how the parents allow their children to talk to them! I think the parents are worried that their children will hate them; but once the kid realizes that the parents care for them enough to prevent brattiness, they will thank them.

Melody said...

Totally agree!

Casey M. said...

Actually I think you're confusing me with Clay...I never needed a spanking...I was very well-behaved. Ahaha

The Isbell Family said...

amen sister!!!!!! I simetimes feel like the worse mom ever bc I feel like its all I do is spank Bro but I know that its for the best for him and I also know that I'm doing the right thing when he gets a spank and he then wants to kiss and hug me and he then proceeds to tell me that he loves me kids need to know their limits and we as parents are the ones to show them I know I'm no expert but I do try... oh yeah and your moms comment is funny lol

Archive